TTDDESTT 824

Seoul Seminar Asks Why Tourism Measures War's Cost, Not Its Own Peace Role

A Seoul seminar backed by South Korea's unification ministry challenged tourism bodies to measure peacebuilding, citing two million Kumgang visitors ended by one 2008 shooting.

Tourism Cannot Be an Industry of Peace While Remaining Silent on War
Tourism Cannot Be an Industry of Peace While Remaining Silent on WarRandgruppe / pixabay

Itinerary

  1. About 2 million South Koreans visited Mount Kumgang between 1998 and 2008; the program ended after a 2008 shooting of a tourist.
  2. SONOSA, with support from South Korea's Ministry of Unification, held the seminar on November 10 in Seoul.
  3. Kwang Chul Choi proposed a Peace Tourism Belt from Seoul through the DMZ, Pyongyang and Mount Kumgang.
  4. The analysis proposes five actions including a tourism peace and conflict observatory.
  5. The argument is anchored to UN Sustainable Development Goal 16 on peace and institutions.

Roughly two million South Koreans visited North Korea's Mount Kumgang between 1998 and 2008 — and then a single shooting ended the program. That figure, cited at a November 10 seminar in Seoul, frames the core question now facing travel trade bodies: why does tourism count the cost of war but never measures its own contribution to preventing conflict?

The seminar, organized by the South-North Korea Exchange and Cooperation Support Association (SONOSA) with support from South Korea's Ministry of Unification, was covered by veteran tourism journalist Imtiaz Muqbil of Travel Impact Newswire. Its distinct feature was the attempt to link historical experience, academic research, cross-border engagement and tourism policy in one discussion.

The Kumgang precedent carries hard commercial lessons. In 2008, a North Korean soldier shot and killed a South Korean tourist, and the tourism program was suspended. Tourism did not prevent the tragedy, and commercial interests could not override the resulting security and political crisis.

What was proposed on the Korean Peninsula?

Kwang Chul Choi, president of the Korean American Public Action Committee, proposed a Peace Tourism Belt linking Seoul, the Demilitarized Zone, Pyongyang, the Wonsan-Kalma coast and Mount Kumgang. Such a corridor could, in theory, generate economic opportunities, reconnect divided communities and open people-to-people channels.

Professor Atsuhito Isozaki of Keio University added a caution from Japanese tourism to North Korea: the country's tourism policies have historically served economic, ideological and political objectives. Opening a destination to foreign visitors does not automatically open its society.

The takeaway: peace tourism should be judged not by visitor counts across a border but by whether crossings build trust, safety, human dignity and sustainable relationships.

What did Berlin, Ireland and Cyprus contribute?

Anna von Arnim Rosenthal of the Berlin Wall Foundation described how, after the Wall opened in November 1989, artists transformed surviving sections into the East Side Gallery. Visitors now encounter a history of separation, repression, courage and reconciliation. The lesson is precise: tourism did not bring down the Wall — political change, diplomacy and civic movements did. Tourism subsequently preserved, interpreted and internationalized the memory.

In Cyprus, Professor Katerina Antoniou presented peacebuilding tourism as civic diplomacy, built on reciprocity. Visitors should not arrive claiming solutions to conflicts they barely understand; they should listen, learn and support locally defined priorities. Ireland's experience, also presented, reinforced the value of historical and community perspectives over promotional slogans.

What does this mean for WTTC and UN Tourism?

The seminar raises an agenda item for both bodies. The WTTC represents private-sector interests; UN Tourism works within the UN system on cooperation, policy and sustainable development. Neither can negotiate peace treaties. Both can shape industry priorities — and an editorial analysis accompanying Muqbil's reporting suggests what a credible initiative could measure:

  • A tourism peace and conflict observatory tracking border closures, lost livelihoods and damaged infrastructure
  • Peacebuilding on the agendas of WTTC, UN Tourism and PATA conferences, with conflict researchers included
  • Destination-level peace tourism strategies covering cultural exchange and visitor safety
  • A meaningful voice for SMEs and border communities in restoring cross-border connections
  • Evaluation against measurable outcomes in cooperation and community benefit, not declarations

The industry already has enough declarations, the analysis argues. What is missing is an accountable framework linking peacebuilding objectives to measurable tourism outcomes — and an acknowledgment that tourism can aggravate conflict through exclusion, unequal development or the commercialization of contested heritage.

Who pays when borders close?

The distribution of risk is uneven. Major international operators can redirect investment, shift capacity or suspend operations when a destination destabilizes. A family-owned hotel near a border crossing cannot relocate; neither can a restaurant, guide, taxi operator or small tour company dependent on cross-border visitors.

The analysis also ties the argument to Sustainable Development Goal 16, which addresses peace, justice and strong institutions. A destination cannot build a sustainable tourism economy while its infrastructure is destroyed, its population displaced or its borders closed. Peace is not a competitor to environmental protection — it is often a precondition for it.

The Seoul seminar's own organizers note the limits: German reunification cannot be replicated in Korea, and the Irish process cannot be copied into Cyprus. Whether the global tourism establishment turns this conversation into action remains an open question.

via eTurboNews (Source)

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering technology and product news in Tourism industry coverage for trade professionals at Travel Trade Desk.

572 articles

Also boarding · Related articles

« Previous flight