TTDDESTT 801

Jamaica's Bartlett Proposes Ten-Gap Test for Destination Resilience

Jamaica's Edmund Bartlett proposed a ten-gap resilience assessment framework in a November 10 address, shifting the global debate from recognition to measurable accountability.

Edmund Bartlett’s Tourism Resilience Revolution: Can the World Turn Promises Into Protection?
Edmund Bartlett’s Tourism Resilience Revolution: Can the World Turn Promises Into Protection?d_alexander33 / pixabay

Itinerary

  1. Bartlett proposed a Tourism Resilience Gap Assessment Framework covering ten gaps in a November 10 address linked to the JICA Chair Program.
  2. Jamaica established the Global Tourism Resilience and Crisis Management Center in 2018.
  3. The UN has designated 2027 the International Year of Sustainable and Resilient Tourism.
  4. The framework remains a proposal with no finalized methodology, financing or monitoring system.

Jamaica's Tourism Minister Edmund Bartlett used a November 10 address, delivered in connection with the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) Chair Program, to propose a Tourism Resilience Gap Assessment Framework built around ten measurable gaps — the first serious attempt to convert a decade of resilience advocacy into an operational audit tool for destinations.

The move signals a shift in the global resilience movement from international recognition toward accountability. Jamaica established the Global Tourism Resilience and Crisis Management Center (GTRCMC) in 2018, and the United Nations later recognized Global Tourism Resilience Day. Bartlett, widely regarded as a founding figure of the resilience movement, now argues those milestones are insufficient. His central message was unusually direct:

"Recognition is not resilience."

The distinction matters commercially. International declarations do not restore electricity after hurricanes, rescue financially distressed small hotels, or guarantee income for tourism workers during months without visitors.

What would the framework measure?

The proposed assessment would examine ten interconnected gaps:

  • Governance
  • Knowledge
  • Technology
  • Financing
  • Infrastructure
  • Workforce preparedness
  • Community protection
  • Environmental sustainability
  • Supply chains
  • Recovery capacity

If implemented effectively, the framework could turn political ambition into a practical tool for governments, destinations and investors. But it remains a proposal. The address did not set out a finalized methodology, a financing mechanism, an implementation timetable, or an independent monitoring system.

Why the geopolitical gap matters

Bartlett's speech arrives amid threats no single destination can manage alone: wars disrupting airspace, sanctions undermining connectivity, and climate pressure on coastal and island economies dependent on foreign airlines, overseas suppliers and international visitors.

That exposes a structural contradiction: tourism is globally interconnected, but responsibility for protecting it remains largely national. A Caribbean island cannot control fuel costs driven by geopolitical tension. A small tourism enterprise cannot finance climate adaptation infrastructure. The framework can identify such vulnerabilities, but measuring them is not solving them. Notably, the speech does not specify how destinations should respond to sanctions, armed conflict, or politically motivated travel restrictions.

Why Japan matters — and why 2027 is the test

The proposed Jamaica-Japan cooperation pairs Japan's disaster preparedness experience with Jamaica's perspective as a tourism-dependent small island economy. Together they could build tools adaptable to destinations with different financial and institutional capacity.

The United Nations has designated 2027 the International Year of Sustainable and Resilient Tourism. Bartlett's initiative could complement UN Tourism's preparations rather than compete with them, ideally producing a shared, internationally credible measurement standard involving UN Tourism, the World Travel & Tourism Council (WTTC), development institutions, academia and destinations themselves — with assessments tied directly to investment and development assistance.

Who pays, who measures, who benefits?

Bartlett's work, alongside Professor Lloyd Waller and other partners, gave the movement institutional momentum. But his own speech invites harder questions:

  • Who pays? The framework must unlock funding for vulnerable destinations and small businesses, not just produce lists of needs they cannot afford to address.
  • Who measures? Assessments must be transparent, independently evaluated and comparable across destinations.
  • Who benefits? Resilience must protect workers and local entrepreneurs, not only major hotels and established investors.

A further question sits beneath all three: can a destination become genuinely resilient while remaining excessively dependent on tourism itself? Diversifying visitor markets helps; diversifying the wider economy may matter more.

Bartlett's legacy will not rest on how often the world celebrates resilience, but on whether a small hotel stays open and a community recovers faster when the next crisis arrives.

via untourism.int (Original)

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering technology and product news in Tourism industry coverage for trade professionals at Travel Trade Desk.

572 articles

Also boarding · Related articles

« Previous flight