TTDHOSTT 571

Hotels Lost $2.3 Billion in Kept Revenue Last Year as Costs Bite

Hotels lost $2.3 billion in kept revenue last year as capture fell 1.11 points; Kalibri sees expenses growing 5-10% yearly against flat-to-3% RevPAR growth.

U.S. Hotels Are Keeping Less and Less of Every Guest Dollar
U.S. Hotels Are Keeping Less and Less of Every Guest DollarOleksandrPidvalnyi / pixabay

Itinerary

  1. Revenue capture fell 1.11 percentage points last year, costing U.S. hotels $2.3 billion in kept revenue and nearly $30 billion in asset value.
  2. Kalibri forecasts expense growth of 5-10% per year against RevPAR growth of flat to 3%.
  3. Construction costs are up about 50% in five years; a stick-built Home2 Suites costs $250,000 per key.
  4. Conversions exceeded 40% of Marriott's openings in the first nine months of this year.
  5. Luxury chains raised rates 9% in Q3 versus 1% for budget properties.

U.S. hotels left $2.3 billion on the table last year as the share of each guest dollar they actually keep slipped again — and the firms tracking the numbers expect the squeeze to tighten.

Fresh data presented at the Skift Commerce Summit shows a structural gap opening between topline growth and owner economics. Kalibri, the hotel analytics firm, measured "revenue capture" — the share of guest spending a hotel keeps after customer acquisition costs — falling 1.11 percentage points last year. Had it held flat, U.S. hotels would have kept $2.3 billion more in revenue, and asset values would stand almost $30 billion higher.

What's driving the squeeze?

Kalibri CEO and co-founder Cindy Estis Green laid out the cost stack: labor, insurance, taxes, debt service, renovation costs, utilities, and customer acquisition have all been rising faster than average room rates in recent years. Her forecast is blunt — expenses growing 5% to 10% a year against RevPAR growth of flat to 3%.

That math means even a strong revenue year doesn't reach the bottom line. U.S. RevPAR is forecast to rise 4.4% this year, according to CoStar and Tourism Economics, after a 0.3% decline last year. The topline looks healthy; the share of it that belongs to the building's owner keeps shrinking.

"Business is great right now," said Tyler Morse, chairman and CEO of MCR, one of the country's largest hotel owners, whose portfolio includes the Hyatt Regency O'Hare Chicago. Both executives described the same squeeze from different vantage points — one measuring it, one living it.

Is new construction still viable?

Barely, by Morse's arithmetic. Construction costs are up roughly 50% in five years, and a stick-built Home2 Suites now runs about $250,000 per key. That math doesn't work without a $200 average daily rate — well above what most select-service markets can command.

The market's answer is shifting toward conversions. More than 40% of Marriott's hotel openings in the first nine months of this year were conversions of existing properties, while new-build starts in the U.S. and Canada remained below pre-pandemic levels. For brands and franchise sellers, that changes the growth playbook: reflagging, not ground-up development, is where unit expansion is coming from.

Where does luxury fit?

Luxury is pulling away from the rest of the chain scale spectrum. Luxury chains raised rates 9% in the third quarter, against just 1% for budget properties. The demand engine behind that spread: the number of U.S. ultra-wealthy individuals has more than doubled in inflation-adjusted terms since 2005.

The gap matters for sellers of travel. High-end inventory can push rate without denting occupancy; economy properties cannot, and their owners absorb the cost inflation instead. Distribution economics follow that divergence.

Who pays for the next distribution shift?

Both executives pointed at AI search as the next line item. Morse predicted AI-driven search would develop paid-placement economics resembling Google's, with one dominant player emerging. Estis Green was more direct about where the cost lands: it's always the owner who ends up paying.

If AI intermediaries replicate the commission-and-bidding structure of the last search era, customer acquisition costs — already outpacing rate growth — would climb again, and revenue capture could fall further.

Takeaway in plain words: hotel revenue is growing, but owners are keeping a smaller slice of it every year, and neither cost curves nor AI-era distribution give them relief soon.

via Skift (Source)

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around Tourism industry coverage for trade professionals at Travel Trade Desk.

585 articles

Also boarding · Related articles

« Previous flightNext flight »